9th Circuit vacates tribal jurisdiction ruling
Friday, February 2, 2007
Filed Under:
Law
In a reversal, the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals on Thursday vacated an earlier ruling that said the Navajo Nation lacked jurisdiction to hear a lawsuit involving Ford Motor Company.
The 9th Circuit said it wasn't clear that the matter couldn't be heard in tribal court. So a three-judge panel stayed action until Ford exhausts all of its tribal remedies, including appellate review.
The case arose over the death of Esther Todecheene, a tribal member and tribal police officer. She was killed while patrolling the reservation in a Ford Expedition.
Todecheene's parents sued Ford in tribal court, claiming the vehicle was defective. But automotive giant challenged the tribe's jurisdiction and asked a federal court to intervene.
In September 2002, U.S. District Judge Paul G. Rosenblatt of Arizona sided with the company. He said Ford, as a non-tribal party, wasn't subject to tribal jurisdiction without consent.
The 9th Circuit agreed in January 2005. But after letting a similar case involving a wrongful death lawsuit on the Flathead Reservation in Montana go forward, the court said the Navajo courts should have a chance to consider whether it has jurisdiction.
"[T]he federal policy supporting tribal self-government directs a federal court to stay its hand in order to give the
tribal court a full opportunity to determine its own jurisdiction," a three-judge panel wrote, citing U.S. Supreme Court precedent.
Get the Order:
Ford Motor Company v. Todecheene
(February 1, 2007)
Vacated Decision:
Ford Motor Company v. Todecheene (Janaury 11, 2005)
Related Stories:
Appeals court upholds tribal jurisdiction after
rehearing (01/11)
Appeals court to rehear
tribal jurisdiction case (06/08)
Appeals
court rules against tribal jurisdiction (08/09)
Tribal authority over all Indians still unsettled
question (06/23)
Supreme Court affirms
tribal powers over all Indians (04/20)
Tribal court can't hear tribal cop case
(11/1)
Appeals court
won't recognize tribal authority (10/15)
Tribes rally in support of
sovereignty (10/8)
Tribes seek to
overturn Supreme Court (2/27)
Inouye
challenges tribes on sovereignty (2/26)
Supreme Court bars
state officials from tribal suit (6/26)
O'Connor defends
tribes amidst squabbling (6/26)
Indian Country cops
face setbacks (5/7)
Norton listens to
tribal police tragedies (5/3)
BIA Cops: In the
Line of Fire (5/2)
Copyright © Indianz.Com
Subscribe