PBS Newshour: Indian issues in presidential race
Tuesday, June 3, 2008
Filed Under:
Politics
"Sens. Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton are courting the Native vote and their pitches both revolve around improving the educational systems in Indian country. Obama stopped at the Crow Indian Reservation in Montana to make his case. Former president Bill Clinton campaigned for his wife on the Pine Ridge reservation in South Dakota while Sen. Clinton made a stop on the Flathead reservation near Glacier National Park.
While crisscrossing these reservations, both candidates have focused their tribal platforms on the improvement of educational resources. Clinton has pledged to repeal the hotly-debated No Child Left Behind Act and Obama has pledged to invest more money into Indian education and reform NCLB.
But for many within the Indian community, their concerns reach beyond these top-line policy goals, focusing instead on how standardized tests and uniform curriculum could undercut traditional teachings and native language learning. Despite repeated attempts to contact both campaigns, no calls or e-mails were returned to clarify the candidates' stands on the complex issue, and experts say the problem is much more intricate then simply reforming or repealing the No Child Left Behind Act.
"The issue for Indian tribes in society is yes, they want to be educated but at what cost?" said David Beaulieu, director of the Center for Indian Education at Arizona State University. "We have to give up who we are as peoples, our languages, our heritage, our cultures in order to become educated? It is possible to have your cake and eat it too."
The Native American system of education was born more than 130 years ago in 1875 when a group of Kiowa, Cheyenne and Arapahoe prisoners of war were taken to Fort Marion prison in Florida. Their internment became the model for Indian education: the Indian boarding school."
Get the Story:
Education Issues Weigh on Tribal Voters in South Dakota, Montana
(PBS Newshour 6/2)
Related Stories:
UK Paper: Clinton campaign dies on reservation
(6/2)
Tribal leaders encouraged by
campaign visits (5/30)
Editorial: Sen.
Clinton better on Indian issues (5/30)
Editorial: To Sen. Obama on Montana's tribes
(5/30)
Kevin Abourezk: Sen. McCain makes
Indian pledge (5/30)
Opinion: John
McCain, a passion for doing right (5/30)
Sen. Obama started Indian outreach early (5/29)
Early voting pushed on South Dakota
reservations (5/29)
Pine Ridge
Republican backs Clinton over Obama (5/29)
Column: Indian vote courted in presidential year
(5/29)
Column: Clinton campaigns in the
Badlands (5/29)
Sen. Clinton campaigns
on Flathead Reservation (5/28)
Sen.
Clinton interview with South Dakota paper (5/28)
Sen. Clinton to campaign on Pine Ridge Reservation
(5/27)
Sen. McCain meets with tribal
leaders in New Mexico (5/27)
Sen. McCain
touts Indian experience over Obama (5/27)
Eastern Shoshone teen endorses Sen. Obama
(5/27)
Opinion: Candidates refuse Indian
contributions (5/23)
Editorial:
Lobbyists run McCain and Obama campaigns (5/23)
Jodi Rave: Sen. Obama eyes Democratic nomination
(5/22)
Sen. Clinton to campaign on
reservations (5/22)
The Native Voice: On
the trail with Sen. Obama (5/21)
Sen.
Clinton courts Indian vote in South Dakota (5/21)
The Native Voice: On the trail with Sen. Obama
(5/20)
Jodi Rave: Sen. Obama first to
visit reservation (5/20)
Crow Tribe
welcomes Sen. Obama to reservation (5/20)
The Native Voice: On the trail with Sen. Obama
(5/19)
Oregon Tribal Leaders: Why we
support Sen. Obama (5/19)
Sen. Obama to
hold rally on Crow Reservation (5/19)
Sen. Clinton reiterates Indian health support
(5/16)
Bill Clinton campaigns on Pine
Ridge Reservation (5/15)
Jodi Rave: A
candidate for the youngest generation (5/15)
Jodi Rave: Clinton and Obama court Indian vote
(5/14)
Clinton and Obama eye Indian vote
in South Dakota (5/14)
Column: Russell
Means predicts Obama win in 2008 (5/14)
Bill Clinton to campaign on Pine Ridge Reservation
(5/13)
South Dakota Indians back Clinton
for president (5/12)
Indian
superdelegate backs Obama for president (5/12)
Cherokee chief praises Obama as 'good president'
(5/12)
New Mexico selects Indian
superdelegate (5/9)
Kevin Abourezk:
Obama and McCain on Indians (5/9)
Counting the Indian vote in North Carolina
(5/8)
Sen. Obama and Sen. Clinton share
primary victories (5/7)
Jodi Rave: Obama
secures Indian superdelegates (5/6)
Sen.
Obama welcomes Kalyn Free's endorsement (5/6)
Clinton and Obama back Lumbee recognition (5/6)
Superdelegate Kalyn Free endorses Sen. Obama
(5/5)
Abourezk: Crow man spreads Obama's
message (5/2)
Copyright © Indianz.Com
Subscribe