Appeals court decision in Dakota trust case
Tuesday, March 10, 2009
Filed Under:
Law
|
Trust
The
Interior Department does not owe a trust responsibility to Dakota descendants who were promised land in the late 1800s, the
Federal Circuit Court of Appeals ruled today.
The plaintiffs to the
Wolfchild case said they are owed money for the federal government's failure to hold land in trust for them. The land is now part of the Shakopee, Prairie Island and Lower Sioux reservations in Minnesota.
A federal judge sided with the plaintiffs but the appeals court today reversed. At issue were three appropriations acts that referred to land to be held in trust for the "loyal" Mdewakanton, or Dakota, people.
"While it is true that a statute need not contain the word 'trust' in order to create a trust relationship, the failure to use that term gives rise to doubt that a trust relationship was intended," the court wrote.
But even if the acts created a trust, Congress terminated it with a law in 1980 that affirmed the land in question is part of the Shakopee, Prairie Island and Lower Sioux reservations, the court added.
Court Decision:
Wolfchild v US (March 10, 2009)
Related Stories:
Judge expands Dakota trust mismanagement suit (4/30)
Dakota descendants fight for
land trust rights (4/23)
Dakota
descendants await payment in trust case (8/14)
Judge reaffirms ruling in Dakota trust fund lawsuit
(12/19)
Meetings set in Mdewakanton trust fund lawsuit
(01/28)
Dakota descendants win round in
trust fund case (10/29)
Dakota
descendants file trust mismanagement suit (11/19)
Minn. tribes challenged on membership policies
(11/17)
Copyright © Indianz.Com
Subscribe